Capell & Howard Secures $12.2 Million Verdict for Tanner Against Stantec
November 20, 2026
Jury awards full damages over required bridge-deck inspections
A Mobile County jury awarded Tanner Construction Company, Inc. $12,206,688 against Stantec Consulting Services, Inc. Circuit Judge Jill Parrish Phillips entered final judgment for the full amount on November 6, 2026.
“This verdict holds Stantec accountable for failing to perform the required inspections. Those wet checks could have identified and corrected the issues in the field. After years of being blamed, Tanner has been fully vindicated and compensated for the harm Stantec’s negligence caused,” said J. Lister Hubbard, lead trial counsel for Tanner and senior shareholder at Capell & Howard.
Tanner was represented by Capell & Howard attorneys J. Lister Hubbard, R. Brooke Lawson III, and J. Mitchell Sikes.
The case arose from Tanner’s replacement of an Escambia County bridge under a $13.6 million ALDOT contract. Stantec was ALDOT’s on-site engineering and inspection consultant.
ALDOT’s Construction Manual required post-pour “wet checks” to measure concrete cover over reinforcing steel while workable. Stantec did not perform them. After all 13 spans were substantially complete, ALDOT raised clearance concerns, required remediation, defaulted Tanner, and called its performance bond. Tanner showed that if Stantec had performed the required wet checks, any clearance issues could have been identified and corrected in the field before the concrete hardened.
The court held that Stantec owed Tanner a duty of care despite the absence of a direct contract. In October 2024, the court found that the professional standard of care required wet checks and that Stantec breached that standard. The jury found that Stantec’s negligence caused Tanner’s losses and awarded the full damages requested.

